"Plastic wheel" sounds like the opposite of 2.5 tonnes. But walk through any die-transfer bay or shipyard and look down: the wheels under the heaviest loads are cream-colored nylon. There's real engineering behind it.
PU is elastic — that's why it's quiet and floor-friendly, and also why it has a ceiling: under extreme load, the tread compresses, heat builds, and the bond between tread and core becomes the failure point. PA nylon barely compresses. Its load limit is set by the steel around it, not the wheel material. That's why the same 75mm nylon wheel carries 1,300kg at 6×3", 1,500kg at 8×3" and 2,500kg at 10×3" — the bracket is the limit, not the wheel.
Two honest trade-offs:
What nylon gives back: zero swelling in oil and coolant, zero rust, and rolling resistance so low that a 2-ton cart starts by hand. On long pushes, that last point is worth more than any spec number.
At these loads the wheel is never the first thing to fail — the mount is. That's why the extra-heavy nylon builds pair the wheel with a 10mm plate and 10mm fork (190×140mm, 146×106mm spacing, Ø14mm holes) and a 6205 large bearing. Size the structure to the load and the nylon wheel will outlive the cart it's bolted to.
If your floor is epoxy or tile, or your loads sit static for weeks on soft concrete, choose the orange PU iron-core build instead — same extra-heavy structure, floor-friendly tread. Environment first, load second, always.